Milton Bradley produced four jigsaw puzzles, using art drawn by cover artist Hodges Soileau. The pictures used included:
- Stacey at a beauty parlor - originally appeared in one of the BSC Calendars
- Mary Anne and the BSC roller skating - from the cover of #46 Mary Anne Misses Logan
- The BSC at a sleepover - originally appeared on the cover of the 1991 BSC calendar, as well as the VHS tape of The Baby-sitters Remember (TV episode).
- Mallory and other raking leaves - from the cover of #47 Mallory on Strike
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.